Monday, January 22, 2007

Images of Altruism

Three different people have e-mailed me this study, which seems to be making the rounds in the news.

The article, published in an upcomming issue of Nature Neuroscience, looked at fMRI images of subjects' brains as they played a game with a computer. They also asked subjects to complete a range of measures, including altruism, empathy and other personality questionnaires. They found that activity in the posterior superior temporal cortex (pSTC) during the game was associated with self-reported altruism but not with any of the personality measures.

They point out that the pSTC has previously been linked to understanding of intentionality. For instance, when subjects see geometric objects moving with seeming purpose across a screen, the pSTC becomes active, but not when the objects move at random. The authors suggest that altruism requires an understanding of agency - what I would call, although the authors do not, Theory of Mind. Because pSTC activity was not linked to the personality measures such as empathic tendency, they suggest that the pSTC acts independently of empathy and other personality measures.



I'm not surprised by the result. Why would you help someone unless you appreciate that they're an indepedent being, capable of acting with purpose and therefore also capable of suffering? Very young children don't grasp this concept. In a common experiment, children are shown a girl hiding a doll in one of two chests. While she's gone, another person comes in and switches the doll to the other chest. When the girl comes back, the children are asked which chest she should look in. Younger children answer with the chest the doll has been moved to. They can't separate what they know from what the girl knows. They don't quite understand that other people have independent minds like their own. Interestingly, the age when children start to answer "the chest she put it in, she thinks it's still there", is around the same age they start engaging in genuine helping behavior.

The authors of this study found no relationship between understanding - or rather, appreciating - the agency of others, at least as measured by pSTC activation, and empathy. They used the Interpersonal Reactivity Index, the same questionnaire I'm using in my Div III. Looking at their supplemental data you can see that there was a correlation between the empathic concern subscale and pSTC activation. There was a correlation between the perspective-taking subscale of the IRI and OFC activation as well. However, subsequent narrowing down of activation areas into "regions of interest" made this correlation not significant - I don't understand the reasoning for that narrowing-down, as I'm not experienced with MRI studies, but it does seem to me that a relationship between pSTC activation and empathy can't be entirely ruled out.

My other issue with the study is that it's focused around the idea of understanding the agency of others. The game they play is focused on that, as opposed to on straight-out altruistic behavior (subjects played trials for their own gain and for charity, but this was only taken into account after the area of interest was narrowed to the pSTC and the OFC). Basically, what they've established is that the pSTC has some sort of influence on altruism. That's great, but there are a lot of factors that are important for altruism. Sociability, for instance. Because most opportunities for helping behavior require interpersonal interaction of some sort, shy people tend to be less altruistic. My own Div III looks at another factor, tendency to feel personal distress. Other researchers have looked at feelings of social responsibility. All of these are correlated with altruism, and all of them may involve activation of areas in the brain measurable by fMRI. None of these are measured in the study. Which is not to say that this study should have looked at them. It's important to take baby steps. But... I'm not sure the sweeping claims that some articles are making (shame on you, BBC!) are justified.

14 comments:

Nemo85 said...

would the pSTC be part of what is known as mirror neurons? This past year, they tracked down what could be the start of the root of autism using similar methodologies (purpose vs. random images, etc.) and found that there are bodies of cells in the brain that only activate when they try and figure out the behavior of others (in a complete nutshell).

But not all autistics are without alturism. Though, true autism could be viewed as the opposite of altruism (seeing only yourself rather than being able to understand the feelings of others).

You get what I mean? Been a long day...

marie said...

mirror neurons... i thought they were more for physical behaviors, like learning how to dance? maybe they could account for really early dev. delays like not learning how to walk on time, but I don't think they can really blame the little boogers for the soc/com differences we see in autism.

Anonymous said...

So, normal wall coverings will serve the objective. There also other wall like scenery pattern.
You need to be thinking of shopping for a stylish
or intelligent seeking wardrobe with hang rails, shelves and drawers to help keep your baby's cloths, linen as well as other accessories.

Here is my webpage all room Decor games
My web page :: Girls Room Decoration Ideas Photograph

Anonymous said...

You can get essential nutrients from fruits and vegetables;
in fact, you should have at least five servings of these
food items daily. The high rpm motor extracts bulks of the fruit, vegetable or combined juices.
So, when you drink wheatgrass, your body feels it immediately.


my web blog - how to use the magic bullet juicer attachment
Also see my webpage :: citrus juicer amazon

Anonymous said...

It is easier to remove the holder if its not stuck to the
cardboard tubing. It provides the rustic and classic
ambiance to any night party. Summer is here and you are
entertaining on the patio more than inside.


My web blog; Cute Kitchen Table Decor

Anonymous said...

To decorate a classic bedroom with a welcome sight, instead of
having a bench, put in an ornate settee at the foot of the
bed. This gives us a feeling of uneasiness. There is a lot
more to interior design than first meets the eye.


Here is my web-site - painting home interior ideas

Anonymous said...

I all the time used to study piece of writing in news papers but now as I am
a user of net therefore from now I am using net for posts, thanks to web.


Here is my web page ... quantrim reviewed

Anonymous said...

I seriously love your site.. Pleasant colors & theme.
Did you make this website yourself? Please reply back as I'm planning to create my own personal website and would love to find out where you got this from or just what the theme is named. Cheers!

Feel free to visit my webpage; quantrim pills

Anonymous said...

Howdy! I know this is kind of off topic but I was wondering which blog platform are
you using for this website? I'm getting fed up of Wordpress because I've had issues with hackers and I'm looking at alternatives for another platform. I would be awesome if you could point me in the direction of a good platform.

Stop by my website; pain management techniques

Anonymous said...

What a data of un-ambiguity and preserveness of precious experience about unexpected emotions.


Here is my homepage - what is quantrim

Anonymous said...

What i do not understood is actually how you're now not really much more smartly-favored than you may be right now. You're very intelligent.
You understand therefore significantly in terms of this subject, made me individually imagine it from so many various angles.

Its like men and women are not interested until it is one thing to do with
Woman gaga! Your individual stuffs nice. All the time maintain it up!


Feel free to visit my website: commercial juicers

Anonymous said...

I don't leave a comment, however I browsed through some comments on "Images of Altruism". I actually do have 2 questions for you if it's allright.
Is it just me or does it give the impression like some
of these comments come across like they are left by brain dead
individuals? :-P And, if you are posting at additional online
social sites, I would like to keep up with you. Could you post a list of the
complete urls of all your public sites like your Facebook page, twitter feed, or
linkedin profile?

Feel free to surf to my weblog; http://afake.tk/index.php?do=/profile-3386/info

Anonymous said...

Stunning story there. What happened after?
Take care!

Feel free to visit my page ... as seen on tv

Anonymous said...

Hola! I've been reading your weblog for some time now and finally got the bravery to go ahead and give you a shout out from Atascocita Texas! Just wanted to tell you keep up the excellent job!

Also visit my page :: snoring mask